Vankilapsykiatria - Fängelsepsykiatri
A Summary of Prison Mental Health Report – Mainland Tanzania 2017-2022
INTRODUCTION
Worldwide there is a high number of mental illnesses among inmates. Although the challenges of mental health care in prisons are widespread around the world, the problem is even greater in low-income countries. This situation is exacerbated by a lack of sufficient resources to serve them.
Tanzanian prison leaders launched a mental health project in prisons 2007-2022 to tackle the deteriorating mental health services of prison inmates. Actions taken were:
- Short mental health training courses for prison health clinic staff were organized by Prison administration in collaboration with its health sector, local and foreign NGOs and mental health professionals.
- A research project on mental health study in prisons was carried out 2017-2022. This study was the first of its kind in Tanzania. The results thereof are summarized below.
The Goals of The Study
- to assess the prevalence of mental health problems among prisoners in Tanzania mainland,
- to examine mental health care provision and pathways to care within the prison system, and
- to improve understanding of the challenges and realities of mental health issues in prison system.
Methods
- A cross-sectional study of a representative sample of the prison population in Tanzania mainland was carried out. Out of the 517 respondents (417 men and 100 women) asked for consent to be interviewed, 503 (403 men and 100 women) agreed to participate, a 97 percent acceptance rate. First-stage interviews used a main questionnaire for assessing the number of mental health problems among the inmates. Second-stage assessments and interviews were conducted with the inmates, who self-reported a significant level of psychiatric symptoms or had obvious psychiatric problems in the first stage interviews.
- An evaluation of the capacity of the prison clinics to diagnose and manage mental disorders by comparison of the interviews’ findings with the prison clinic case notes.
- In-depth interviews with 34 correctional officers and 9 prison health officers on the material and cultural issues that influence identification and care of inmates with mental health problems.
PREVALENCE OF MENTAL HEALTH PROBLEMS AMONG PRISONERS
Common mental disorders were examined using the CIS-R questionnaire.
- The overall rate of anxiety or depression was 36 percent among men and 31 percent among women.
- Thoughts of weakness emerged in the majority, 45 percent for men and 39 percent for women, followed by feelings of sadness, which were 34 percent male and 33 percent female.
- Concerns about physical health was significantly higher for men 33 percent compared to 22 per cent for women.
Symptoms of probable psychosis were examined using the PSQ questionaire. The presence of any one psychotic symptom was considered positive for probable psychosis. It was found that among men, 52% of detainees and 50% of convicted inmates, had symptoms of probable psychosis. Among women, 24 percent of detainees and 41 percent of the convicted had symptoms of probable psychosis.
The incidence of suicidal ideations among men in the past year was 11 per cent, while for women it was 15 per cent. Reports of suicide attempts in the past year were 3% for men compared to 7% for women. 65% of the prisoners in the high suicide risk group suffered from mood disorder.
Alcohol and drug use a year before entering prison were also inquired. Out of the 487 survey respondents (392 men and 95 women) who answered questions about alcohol consumption a year before entering prison, 10 percent of men and 11 percent of women misused alcohol. Lifetime drug use by male prisoners was 20% compared to 10% of females.
Epilepsy had been found among 7 percent of men and 5 percent of women. At least one symptom of epilepsy was found among 10 percent of men and 5 percent of women.
EVALUATION OF MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES IN PRISON CLINICS
At each research prison, every second prisoner attending a prison clinic during the study week was included in the evaluation. After treatment by prison health staff, the prisoner’s health data was reviewed and the prisoner was interviewed by the research officers.
Psychiatric problems identified by prison health staff was 60 % compared to those identified by research assistants.Their ability to prescribe appropriate medications and accurate doses was below 50 %.
Ten key aspects of the management of mental care and performance evaluation of prison clinic health professionals were examined.The clinical challenges identified by the researchers
- lack of experienced mental health professionals
- lack of access to essential medicines
- lack of a dedicated treatment area for inmates with mental illnesses
- incorrect treatment decisions
- overcrowding in correctional facilities
- the referral rate for psychiatrists was poor in many of the prisons
PRISON OFFICIALS VIEWS ON MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES
Prison officials expressed their views on the state of mental health services in prison:
- Inmates with mental illnesses had difficulty coping with harsh prison living conditions.
- Many were unable to follow prison rules and regulations, explain their needs, seek available assistance or protect themselves.
- Correctional officers found that they had little knowledge of dealing with mental patients. Some of the challenges are suicidal behaviour and frustration because of delayed court cases and lack of justice within the legal system.
- The mentally ill have many needs compared to the limited resources of prisons.
- Inmates and some correctional officers fear that the mentally ill are dangerous, unpredictable, thereby fueling the stigma against the mentally ill.
- Shortages of manpower, funds and equipment to run a range of services are critical.
- The prison security system is weakened by the presence of mentally ill inmates, and limited ability to provide them with effective treatment.
- Prison staff also highlighted systemic and infrastructure issues, which impede access to services for the mentally ill.
- According to prison staff limited space leads to overcrowding of prisoners,to risk of infectious diseases and to hygiene challenges.
- The problem of overcrowding was compounded by delays in police investigations and cases going to court. This is a burden on the prison system, but it also results in high operating costs for the government.
Gaps Encountered During the Study
The supervision of research assistants was based on the use of mobile phones that were not allowed inside the prison for security reasons. Thus, it was impossible to contact the research officers on the spot during the interviews.
Research assistants had little time to fully understand the prison environment in which safety is a priority.
Some prison guards stood nearby enough to hear interviews. Therefore, it was difficult to ensure confidentiality during those interviews and this may have affected how the inmates answered the questions.
Many respondents found the 90-page survey questionnaire exhausting. This may have contributed to the loss of information for some parts.
A large number of answers for questions concerning drug use were incomplete, perhaps because drugs are prohibited in prisons.
CONCLUSION
Research shows high rates of mental illness, resource scarcity and the majority of inmates being a socially disadvantaged group. It is therefore proposed to strengthen human, financial and infrastructural resources to care for the mentally ill in prison.
The report highlights a number of key problems that could guide future policies and plans to improve mental health services in prison.
A large number of mental health problems are associated with scarce resources. Although prison leadership has struggled to strengthen mental health services, progress has been slow. This is due to inadequate funding, old infrastructure, and a lack of mental health professionals.
Many prisoners had existing mental health problems before being incarcerated. Treatment they may have received from their community appeared to be insufficient and inadequate, which indicates lack of mental health services within local communities.
POLICY CHALLENGES AND RECOMMENDATIONS
The Tanzanian prison administration is aware of how mentally ill inmates suffer from resource constraints outlined above.
Improvement of mental health services in prisons is, however, not solely the responsibility of prison authorities. All levels of government, the private sector and voluntary organisations need to work together to develop quality care for mentally ill inmates.
Policy review is necessary to address these problems. Guidance on immediate and long-term action is needed.
The need to increase resources to improve mental health services in the prison system is obvious
- Proper medical and care infrastructure for mentally ill inmates is needed.
- Budget plans tailored to the essential needs of mentally ill inmates (e.g medicines).
- Any attempt to strengthen mental health services in prison will depend on prison staff. Even if referral procedures for inmates with severe mental illness are improved, most mentally ill patients will still need treatment inside the prison.
- Two types of training are essential: Training to build awareness of prison officers about mental health issues, and improve the quality of mental care given by prison health professionals in prison clinics.
- All prison staff should be introduced to topics on mental health during their basic training.
Acknowledgements
At various stages of research implementation, there are many people who have contributed to its success. It was impossible to remember and name everyone who contributed to achieving this role in the implementation stages. We are grateful to all those who participated in the process of achieving our mission. We thank the Commissioner General of Prisons, Elder Ramadan Nyamka and Brg. Suleiman Mzee for overseeing this project. The support and contribution of retired Prison Commissioners: Augustine Nanyaro, John Minja, Dr. Juma Malewa and Faustine Kassike at various stages of the Prison Mental Health Project is greatly appreciated. Much was possible thanks to your cooperation and leadership.
We also appreciate the support and leadership shown by Commissioner Ngarama, Dr. S. Chambuso, Dr. W. Rugamba, Dr. H. Mkwiche, Dr. A. Assey Dr. S. M. Shija and Dr. A. Kachima. We are grateful to the Vaasa Association of Developing Countries (VADC), and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Finland for allocating funds to strengthen mental health services in Tanzania from 2007 to 2022. Working relationship with VADC has been good. Special thanks go to Dr Irja Rantanen-Lakka and Dr Harri Kivela for their unwavering support and followup.
WAANDAAJI WA UTAFITI
Department of Health, Prisons Headquarters
Vaasa Association for Developing Countries (VADC) – Finland
Mental Health Association of Tanzania (MEHATA)
Researchers
Prof. Joseph K. Mbatia – Project Leader – MEHATA
Dr. Irja Rantanen-Lakka – Project Leader -Vaasa
Dr. Harri Kivela -Advisor -Vaasa
Dr. Margaret Hogan – Researcher/Coordinator of Prison Officers’ Opinion
Mr. Abdalla H. Slave – Expert Data
Psy. Mrema Kilonzo – Researcher
Prof. Henrik Gahmberg Expert Advisor
Prof. Rachel M. Jenkins Expert Advisor
